On Monday, Mayor Zohran Mamdani kept true to a key campaign promise by announcing that he would disband the NYPD’s Strategic Response Group. While appeasing extreme anti-police advocates, the move, City Journal contributing editor Rafael Mangual has observed, is primarily cosmetic, enshrining policies already on the books and shifting officers to make it appear as though the SRG has been repurposed out of existence.
Still, the move emboldens critics of the SRG and the NYPD more generally, validating their claims that the group represents a violent threat to free speech. In reality, past deployments of the SRG to protests were often necessary, as in many cases masked lawbreakers had already crossed the line from speech into action.
Finally, a reason to check your email.
Sign up for our free newsletter today.
In April 2024, for instance, activists at City College broke windows, spray painted school property, and released a flare that set a roof on fire. The SRG was deployed at the behest of CUNY leadership. They arrested the agitators and secured the area swiftly, but not before trespassers had caused over $3 million in damages. The miscreants vandalized administrative offices and attempted to barricade themselves in the Financial Aid Office; CUNY was forced to shift classes to online instruction.
On the same day, a similar scene unfolded at Columbia. Masked instigators broke into Hamilton Hall—one activist smashed the windows with a hammer to gain entry—and barricaded it, temporarily holding custodians against their will. The damages were estimated to be in the millions. Columbia’s administration requested that the SRG come to campus; officers made arrests for arson, vandalism, and trespassing.
A year later, masked “protesters” from Columbia University Apartheid Divest—a group that endorses the eradication of Western civilization—pushed security guards and occupied Butler Library. One protester graffitied “Columbia Will Burn” on a glass library encasement. The SRG was once again called to remove the threat.
The SRG has been a vital presence beyond New York’s campuses, too. In 2018, the right-wing Proud Boys staged a protest that escalated when anti-fascist counterprotesters arrived. An all-out brawl broke out, with one person of interest kicking a victim lying on the sidewalk. The SRG arrested members of the Proud Boys, two of whom were sentenced to prison a year later.
Similarly, in 2023, the popular Twitch streamer Kai Cenat announced a giveaway at Union Square Park. Cenat did not alert the NYPD and did not obtain a permit for the giveaway. Thousands of people filled the park, and the massive overflow blocked traffic. Attendees began climbing on vehicles, park gazebos, and statutes, hurling objects at nearby cops and vandalizing cars. At least four people were taken away in ambulances, and the SRG made 65 arrests.
These are just a few instances where the SRG’s training proved integral to restoring order. There are myriad more, including SRG operations during other high-profile mass events such as the George Floyd riots, the attempted bombing at Gracie Mansion earlier this year, and an active-shooter situation on Park Avenue last summer.
The line between protesting and violent action is often blurred by the same people who most adamantly support disbanding the SRG. An increasing number of far-left activists have embraced guerilla tactics to create chaos. One subgroup within the DSA, the Red Rabbits, calls for a “national uprising against federal agents and police brutality” and hosts training seminars showcasing tactics for achieving that end.
Like the Red Rabbits, the Sunrise Movement is heavily focused on protest and direct action. Once known as a youth environmental group, Sunrise has since drifted toward a focus on “anti-fascist” action in opposition to the Trump administration. It also knowingly engages in unlawful protests, whether through building occupations or violations of local ordinances. Sunrise trains its organizers on what to expect in these scenarios and will even use disruptions as social media fodder, purposefully portraying themselves as social justice champions while police, politicians, or even college administrators are cast as the villains. It should come as no surprise that the SRG has had run-ins with Sunrise. Just this year, the SRG was deployed when Sunrise occupied the lobby of a Hilton Hotel in Tribeca, where 66 protesters were arrested. On May Day, the SRG had to remove Sunrise after it blocked the entrance to the New York Stock Exchange.
At a time when “protest” for many has come to mean breaking and entering, arson, graffiti, intimidation, and property damage, we need the SRG more than ever. If Mayor Mamdani really wanted to protect the First Amendment, he would ensure that the radicals who so often violate others’ rights were nowhere to be found at the next scheduled demonstration.