Yesterday, fulfilling a controversial campaign promise, New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani announced that he would disband the NYPD’s Strategic Response Group. Established in 2015 under former NYPD Commissioner Bill Bratton, the SRG was meant to strengthen the department’s ability to respond to mass-casualty events, control large crowds, assist in citywide mobilizations, and bolster the efforts of the department’s Emergency Service Unit. Mamdani’s announcement will excite his political base—but on closer inspection, the move does not represent the dramatic change the mayor suggests.
Mamdani’s announcement has four elements. First, the city will create a First Amendment Support Team (FAST) within the department’s Community Affairs Bureau to liaise with protesters, prioritizing deescalation. Notably, this is something the Community Affairs Bureau’s officers—whom New Yorkers recognize by their bright blue shirts and jackets—already do.
Finally, a reason to check your email.
Sign up for our free newsletter today.
Second, the city will establish a civilian dialogue team, which will be housed within the new Office of Community Safety. Once hired and trained, these civilian responders will take over the duties of communicating on the ground with protesters from the FAST officers. In essence, the plan aims to civilianize what the Community Affairs Bureau has long done. This is perhaps the biggest change being made.
Third, the plan claims to impose a host of new reforms regulating how the NYPD responds to protests. Among them are a ban on the use of tear gas, as well as prohibitions on “kettling” (the barricading of protesters in an enclosure—usually prior to arrest); the carriage of long guns by officers policing protests; and the use of pepper spray for general crowd management.
Again, these prohibitions are already in effect. They are either among the terms outlined in a 2023 settlement agreement between the NYPD and New York Civil Liberties Union, or—in the case of displaying long guns or using tear gas—already reflective of current NYPD practices.
Lastly, the plan calls for the creation of a new, citywide patrol unit: the Patrol Support Division. What are the duties of this unit, which, according to a City Hall press release, will be staffed by officers with specialized training? It will “[S]erve as a resource to patrol, including participating in searches for missing persons, supporting major events,” and “conduct arrests at protests in rare instances, if necessary.” Sound familiar? That’s because it’s essentially what the SRG already did.
It seems that Mamdani is claiming victory on policies already in effect and moving responsibilities around rather than forgoing them. Why, then, is the mayor selling this as a radical change in how things are done at NYPD?
Part of it is that Mamdani is almost a year into his mayoralty and hasn’t made good on any of his public-safety-related promises. The NYPD is still handling most mental-health crisis response and still doing quality-of-life enforcement. The NYPD’s gang database has not been abolished. The police commissioner is still in charge of officer discipline. And the jails on Rikers Island are still open.
Among those other promises, disbanding and repurposing the SRG will likely have the smallest effect on the city’s public safety, at least if the move is as nominal as it seems. Conveniently, the SRG has also been a target of the Democratic Socialists of America, so making good on the promise to dismantle the unit will also earn Mamdani goodwill with his DSA base.
The SRG has drawn the ire of the far Left because of its responses to unruly protests. In September, the mayor reiterated that criticism, telling reporters, “I believe that we should have a focus on counterterrorism that is separate from our response to the use of First Amendment.” He made the same argument last week during a press conference, saying, “I do not believe that the responsibilities of counterterrorism and enforcement and First Amendment response are one and the same.”
But whether protests and terrorist attacks remain separate events isn’t actually up to the mayor. Protests and other large public gatherings can, and often do, devolve into riots, looting sprees, mass shootings, and even terrorism. A 2025 document put out by the federal Joint Counterterrorism Assessment Team (JCAT) warned that “violent extremists remain interested in attacking large public gatherings such as sporting events, music venues, high-profile special events, or symbolic locations.”
New Yorkers don’t have to reach far into the past for an example. Readers will recall the protest outside Gracie Mansion targeted by two ISIS-inspired attackers, who hurled homemade (and, thankfully, defective) pipe bombs at police this past March. And according to the Center for Strategic & International Studies, “In 2021, over half of all domestic terrorist incidents occurred in the context of metropolitan demonstrations.”
Nor is terrorism the only possible threat that might call for the deployment of SRG to a protest. Recall, for example, the destructive riots that took place in New York and throughout the country in the aftermath of George Floyd’s death in 2020. Against that backdrop, the idea that protests are invariably “low-risk” events is naive.
Most protests don’t involve acts of terrorism, of course. But the purpose of a unit like the SRG is rapid response in the case of such rare events. That includes proactive crowd control, threat engagement, and mass-casualty event response.
This makes the SRG an integral part of a broader security strategy. Having officers proficient with heavy weapons and other specialized equipment who are also trained for mass casualty situations available for large public gatherings in a city that remains a target for bad actors shouldn’t be controversial.
Though the disbandment of the SRG may not end up changing much on the ground, Mamdani’s announcement does send a clear message—one sure to embolden the protest coalition and demoralize those called upon to keep order. That may be good politics for the mayor, but it’s bad for the city.