Photo by Zeynep Demir/Anadolu via Getty Images

I met the comedian Russell Brand at Twitter headquarters in 2014. I was working as a camera operator for a short documentary by Ondi Timoner and followed Brand through his performance at Twitter and into the streets of San Francisco. He had an obvious magnetism. He wore a shirt unbuttoned down the chest and a paisley scarf around his neck, like a 1970s rock star. He had the appearance, and perhaps the spirit, of a serpent: his movements, his eyes, his tongue.

I was not surprised, then, by the cascade of news over the past decade accusing Brand of sexual exploitation. Libertinism was, after all, his persona. He made no secret about his appetites and desires—he walked through the offices of Twitter engaging in sexual banter and offering his touch.

The story took a dark turn this month when Brand was convicted of rape and sexual assault. The most serious charge arose from encounters following one of his shows and later at his home. According to testimony at trial, a young woman visited Brand in his dressing room, participated in a three-way sexual encounter, and used her tongue to stimulate the comedian’s anal area. Later, she visited Brand’s London townhouse, where the two engaged in consensual vaginal sex. According to prosecutors, she subsequently withdrew her consent when Brand began to sodomize her.

The details are grotesque, and I have rehashed them only because they were essential for determining Brand’s innocence or guilt during the trial. By all accounts, Brand is a lecher, pervert, abuser, and decadent. But the question at the trial was whether he was a rapist.

The jury answered the charge of rape with a resounding yes. Though the woman consented to the encounter in the dressing room and the initial encounter at Brand’s home, the prosecution argued that the final sordid act was rape. Brand’s trial was decided by Rashomon-style interpretation of the event, which occurred nearly 20 years ago—and, notably, came into public dispute after he had reinvented himself as a right-wing Christian.

The deeper story, however, is not about Russell Brand. It’s about our changing moral consensus in light of the sexual revolution of the 1960s. Left-wing ideologues promised to unleash a Summer of Love and argued that loosening social inhibitions around sex would lead to the liberation of women. It didn’t work out that way. Men like Brand liberated their desires, but women have ricocheted between declarations of “sex positivity” and condemnations of “rape culture.”

The sexual revolution created a profound ambiguity—something we might call schizomoralia—that denied young women a stable guide through the dangers and precarities of sex. As a consequence, many have engaged in activities they later regret and, as a coping mechanism, some have retroactively withdrawn consent. For the outside observer, the line between rape and liberation can sometimes seem hard to discern.

In this sense, the #MeToo campaigns of the past decade represent a kind of Thermidor of the sexual revolution. But the basic tension has not been resolved and the relationship between the sexes has become even more fraught. To many, modern feminism seems to have begun as sexual liberation for women and ended in political revenge against men.

England’s handling of these matters presents another incongruity. Brand was sentenced to ten years in prison for an ambiguous liaison, while some ethnic-minority rapists received much lighter sentences. A few representative cases: Tasawar Hussain, convicted of rape, sentenced to three years in prison; Sajid Mahmood Khan, convicted of raping a teenaged girl, sentenced to three years in prison; Sohail Zaffer, convicted of drugging and raping a girl aged 13 to 16, sentenced to three years and six months in prison.

A separate standard seems to be in place, which allows members of the public to pin their rage on a hated archetype—the last rock star—while denying, obscuring, and rationalizing their feelings about Muslim rapists, mostly out of fear of being branded racist.

The West will have to negotiate this dynamic in the years ahead. The verdict against Brand sets an ambiguous standard that does not resolve the deeper moral dilemmas beneath it. The sexual revolution has turned love into war—one that neither side can win.

Donate

City Journal is a publication of the Manhattan Institute for Policy Research (MI), a leading free-market think tank. Are you interested in supporting the magazine? As a 501(c)(3) nonprofit, donations in support of MI and City Journal are fully tax-deductible as provided by law (EIN #13-2912529).

Further Reading