Protest is a necessary component of a well-functioning democracy, but looking at my own college, the University of Chicago, I cannot help but wonder whether many of today’s protests are really making our democratic institutions healthier. Rather than calling for practical solutions to tangible problems faced by Americans, many of my peers seem more obsessed with abstract, idealistic goals. However, if one is to inspire Americans to view engaging in democracy as an effective means of delivering real benefits, then it is necessary to show that citizens can be brought to act on the most mundane issues, not just the large or abstract ones.
That’s why last month I rallied approximately 30 UChicago students to demonstrate at the Chicago Mercantile Exchange for the repeal of the 1958 Onion Futures Act, a law that makes onions the only crop for which futures markets are banned. Students with For Our Futures, an independent student organization that I lead, displayed protest signs, chanted about free markets, and were joined by a giant inflatable onion to show our support for the cause. Our protest was small, but it garnered real attention, including over 1.5 million views and the notice of various CEOs and government officials.
Finally, a reason to check your email.
Sign up for our free newsletter today.
The Onion Futures Act is not the most important law on the books. But it shows how well-intentioned but unprincipled government interventions can generate real problems. Such mistakes can only be undone if citizens demand it. This ability to correct past errors reveals more about a democracy’s vitality than how often enormous movements succeed in creating new law.
The first onion futures market, in which traders exchanged contracts for future delivery of onions, was established in 1942. By 1955, it had grown so large that it represented 20 percent of the volume traded on the Chicago Mercantile Exchange.
Unfortunately, that same year the market began to unravel. Two commodity traders, Vincent Kosuga and Sam Siegel, acquired roughly 99 percent of the onion futures market. They then threatened to flood it unless onion farmers bought back the onions they were selling.
The deluge happened anyway. By March 1956, 50 pounds of onions sold for half the cost of the sack they came in. With too few buyers to absorb the sudden surge in onion supply, tons of effectively worthless onions were dumped into the Chicago River. Farmers could only watch as their financial distress mounted.
Outraged, the onion farmers pressured Congress for action. Rather than revitalize the onion futures market by barring market manipulation, Congress took the easier route of banning the market altogether. President Dwight Eisenhower signed the Onion Futures Act into law in 1958.
There was nothing special about onions, of course. The same fate could have befallen just about any other semi-perishable crop in the 1950s. Nevertheless, for years lawmakers persisted in the mistaken belief that the onion market was somehow uniquely susceptible and that quick fixes were more politically valuable than systemic solutions. More comprehensive rulemaking about market manipulation would not come for years afterward.
The pain inflicted upon the many traders and onion farmers that relied on this particular futures market still endures today. Today, there are futures in everything from wheat to pork bellies to orange juice concentrate. These markets allow farmers to sell their goods before their produce is ready. By locking in a guaranteed price, farmers can protect themselves against market volatility.
But not onion farmers! They must instead plant their crop without the clear price signals of market demand. The result is that onion prices can fluctuate wildly from year to year. That leaves in significant financial jeopardy the very farmers that the Onion Futures Act was meant to protect.
The onion is not the only crop without a futures market. Nor is it the only crop for which futures have been manipulated. But it is the only crop for which the government has simply prohibited farmers from forming a futures market in the first place.
Besides being harmful from its inception, the Onion Futures Act has become outdated and forgotten. An onion futures market would run more smoothly today than it did in the 1950s. The development of better onion-preservation technology would yield more liquidity for the market. Greater access to foreign markets means more price competition.
Repealing the Onion Futures Act alone will not dramatically alter the daily life of every American. In fact, it would only somewhat improve the lives of a few people. But how many other obscure, antiquated laws are there currently in place, and how consequential might these laws be if aggregated?
This protest movement is the perfect illustration of not only a better approach to policy making but also the necessary role of everyday citizens in making democracy work. The sorts of things my peers protest already command the attention of politicians. By contrast, few of our leaders will ever take the time to read through the thousands of pages of obscure laws on the books—unless, that is, we draw their focus to them.
Though it may sound absurd to say, a successful protest movement to repeal the Onion Futures Act helps show whether American democracy is healthy. If a small group of concerned citizens can still rally for the repeal of a minor but unnecessary law, then perhaps our institutions are not so broken after all.