Photo by Joe Raedle/Getty Images

“Close to an extinction-level event” was how outgoing Florida Governor Ron DeSantis described the 2026 midterm elections. The Republican Party lost heavily everywhere—except Florida.

Florida voters delivered every statewide office on the ballot to the GOP, maintained Republican majorities in both houses of the state legislature, elected DeSantis-appointed incumbent Ashley Moody to finish Secretary of State Marco Rubio’s Senate term, kept all 20 of the 28 House seats previously held by Republicans in party hands, and—by a 62 percent supermajority—passed a DeSantis-backed ballot initiative to cut property taxes. Though small, the GOP’s margins of victory were more comfortable than DeSantis’s razor-thin 0.4 percent advantage in 2018 over Democrat Andrew Gillum.

National Republicans dispirited by their weak congressional leadership should look to Florida, where DeSantis, his administration, and state Republican legislators have worked assiduously to deliver American voters’ clearly expressed electoral mandates from 2024: fiscal conservatism, locally and nationally popular anti-DEI initiatives, and responsible government. Amid a shellacking for the GOP, Florida could show a path forward for the party.

How did Florida Republicans pull it off? Like any other impressive achievement, the best explanation is years of hard work. In Florida, that work stretches all the way back to the state’s first American settlers and the spirit of rugged individualism they inculcated. Those men and women, called “crackers,” got their now racially tainted soubriquet from their willingness to break what was then the South’s toughest soil. After the Civil War, they were joined by planters who claimed and tamed parcels of south Florida’s subtropical wilds to build hard-won farmsteads.

That individualistic spirit laid the groundwork for measures like Florida’s 1924 constitutional amendment banning income and inheritance taxes. Today, that policy has convinced increasingly taxed and ill-served blue-state populations to move here if they can. The state’s freedom-oriented spirit also nudged it toward Covid policies that followed science, limited lockdowns, quickly reopened schools, and resulted—according to Centers for Disease Control figures—in fewer deaths per capita than stricter blue-state regimes like New York and New Jersey.

Florida was, in short, ripe for the mass relocation of beleaguered blue staters and one of the largest interstate transfers of capital in American history. Just eight years ago, when DeSantis narrowly won his first gubernatorial race, the Democrats had a 257,000-registered-voter advantage. Today, Florida has 1.5 million more registered Republicans than Democrats. Even as Republican turnout fell nationally, the GOP’s numbers were high enough to deny the Democrats any major wins.

That advantage has been sustained by good governance as well as demographics. During DeSantis’s two terms, Florida’s debt has been roughly halved even as the national debt—currently managed by federal Republicans—has swelled to all-time highs. The Sunshine State’s budget is less than half the size of New York’s despite Florida’s having 17 percent more residents.

Florida’s fiscal prudence has translated into real advantages for residents of all backgrounds and walks of life. In addition to being free from income and inheritance taxes, Floridians now also benefit from universal school vouchers; reductions in tolls, fees, licensing, and state university tuition; meaningful plans to address rising health-care and insurance costs; and the massive property-tax exemption just approved by ballot initiative.

Florida Republicans have also delivered on culture war promises. Despite some resistance and backsliding, the state has codified popular anti-DEI initiatives with broad application to state institutions, contractors, grantors, tax incentives, and virtually all other official business. By law, biological males can’t play girls’ sports, bathrooms are sex-specific, sex-reassignment surgeries for minors are criminal acts, public school libraries are free of sexualized materials, and local government officials who violate state or federal directives on subjects ranging from criminal sentencing to immigration enforcement can be suspended from office for neglect of duty or incompetence. Despite two years with majorities in both houses of Congress, a Republican president in the White House who issued relevant executive orders, and a 6–3 Supreme Court majority, the national GOP has passed no legislation on any of these issues.

The national implications are clear. As the GOP floundered everywhere else, Florida’s brand of active, hands-on, results-based conservatism won in 2026.

Early bets for 2028 are emerging, and two Floridians are already surging ahead in the race to replace the Florida resident currently in the White House. According to a post-midterm Reuters poll rating the “excellence” of hypothetical presidential candidates, Rubio is now favored 45 percent to 43 percent over Vice President J. D. Vance, while Governor DeSantis made a strong showing at 32 percent. Nationwide, Republican leaders may yet realize that the future is Floridian.

Donate

City Journal is a publication of the Manhattan Institute for Policy Research (MI), a leading free-market think tank. Are you interested in supporting the magazine? As a 501(c)(3) nonprofit, donations in support of MI and City Journal are fully tax-deductible as provided by law (EIN #13-2912529).

Further Reading