Photo by Bill Pugliano/Getty Images

“By shifting the language,” Michael Crawford told his audience, they could “show the concepts of diversity or equity or inclusion without using the words that some people find triggering.”

Crawford was speaking at a virtual training hosted last year by Spitfire Strategies, where he serves as vice president. A few minutes later, Jen Carnig, Spitfire’s president, reiterated the message in a recording I obtained: “Now keep in mind, again, we use the phrase ‘fair opportunity’ instead of ‘equity.’”

Spitfire Strategies, as Carnig explained in the recording, is a communications firm that “works exclusively on racial, economic, and climate justice.” Since last year, the firm has worked closely with the Alliance for Higher Education, a hub for dozens of nonprofits seeking to “defend” higher education—and DEI. As I’ve previously reported, the alliance has been quietly spearheaded by the Andrew W. Mellon Foundation, which has long thrown big money behind campus social justice initiatives.

The alliance is Mellon’s tool for fighting reform. Spitfire, it appears, provides the playbook.

When it comes to DEI, Spitfire’s strategy is simple: “shift your language but never your values,” as one of its documents puts it.

Through public records requests, I’ve obtained strategy documents, training slides, videos, and emails from Spitfire Strategies. The records show how the firm has trained university administrators and nonprofit leaders, encouraging them to fight for “diversity, equity, and inclusion” while scrubbing those terms from their vocabulary.

The records give a glimpse into the machinations of the academic resistance. Emails show Spitfire consultants corresponding with a small but well-organized cadre, including Jeremy Young, a senior advisor for the American Association of Colleges and Universities (AAC&U); Isaac Kamola, who leads a center at the American Association of University Professors (AAUP); and Mike Gavin, president of the Alliance for Higher Education. As I’ve previously reported, all three receive funding from Mellon.

In that messaging playbook, which is titled “Shift Terms, Not Values,” Spitfire makes the case for an entirely new vocabulary. University leaders should use terms like “different perspectives” instead of “diversity,” the guide explains. They should say “equal opportunity for all” instead of “equity.” And instead of “inclusion,” the guide recommends explaining how students should be free “to ask questions, explore ideas and learn from one another.”

Spitfire’s playbook is sober about the average American’s attitude toward DEI. “‘Equity’ has perhaps been too weaponized in its association with ‘diversity, equity and inclusion,’ and for some, it suggests preferential treatment,” it notes. “Leaning into equality and fairness resonates more deeply.”

These negative connotations, Spitfire asserts, are the result of “extremists” who have run successful smear campaigns. “One of the top findings in the research,” the guide notes, “is just how much the opposition has effectively weaponized the phrase ‘diversity, equity and inclusion’ and its acronym ‘DEI.’” The better approach, the firm argues, is to simply drop the terms altogether.

Some of Spitfire’s suggestions could create confusion. A few years ago, the distinction between equity and equality was a sacrosanct talking point. Faculty, administrators, politicians, and pundits repeated the trope to argue that “equality” was not enough. As I reported in 2023, at Texas Tech, one faculty job applicant was penalized for not being able to explain the distinction. Now Spitfire’s messaging strategy calls for doing away with this distinction—but without any change in substance.

Framing the debate as a matter of messaging, Spitfire’s consultants emphasize keeping their strategy a secret. “Please do not share this resource widely,” Jenny Kern, a Spitfire vice president, wrote in an email to a group including Young, Kamola, and Gavin. “We don’t want to give the opposition our messaging playbook.” Lillian Simko, a Spitfire account executive, said the same thing in a different email. Passing along meeting slides, Tessa Carreiro, a Spitfire account executive, told the group: “As a reminder, please do not share these materials widely.”

Spitfire’s online training sessions attracted an eclectic list of attendees, hailing from universities, academic societies, and nonprofits. In two training sessions I viewed, participants included Alex Levy, director of communications at the American Historical Association; Ava McLaughlin, a program assistant at Mellon; and Alisha Knight, chief diversity officer at Johns Hopkins University.

Spitfire has also worked directly with other nonprofits in Mellon’s orbit. With the American Association of Colleges and Universities, it created a messaging guide on how to “advance public trust” in higher education, as a part of a project run by Jeremy Young. Young previously worked on a Mellon-funded project with PEN America before starting a Mellon-bankrolled project at the AAC&U.

Some clients have adopted Spitfire’s strategy wholesale. As I’ve previously reported, the president of the Alliance for Higher Education, Mike Gavin, privately made plans to “protect and/or rebuild DEI” at the group’s soft launch. Before this year, Gavin had written about the need for a new group with “an unapologetic, visionary commitment to diversity, equity, and inclusion.” Since the alliance launched publicly in January, however, its website makes no reference to DEI, promising instead to fight for “a fair opportunity so that all students, faculty, and staff are represented and thrive,” borrowing Spitfire’s language. Its “blueprint” for higher education reform employs Gavin’s turn of phrase without using the term “DEI” itself, in describing goals that include “establish[ing] an unapologetic, visionary commitment to ensuring people from all walks of life are represented, belong, and thrive in our institutions.”

Following their blowout midterm victory, some Democrats have already heralded the return of identity politics. As election results rolled in, Congressman Ro Khanna posted a celebratory video on social media with the caption “DEI is back!” As Spitfire’s playbook shows, it never quite went away; instead, the diversity bureaucracy’s staunchest defenders just started using different words to describe it.

Donate

City Journal is a publication of the Manhattan Institute for Policy Research (MI), a leading free-market think tank. Are you interested in supporting the magazine? As a 501(c)(3) nonprofit, donations in support of MI and City Journal are fully tax-deductible as provided by law (EIN #13-2912529).

Further Reading