Photo by Sean Gallup/Getty Images

While it may be the world’s most valuable company, Nvidia is also a Delaware corporation, and Delaware follows traditional principles of corporate law. The most basic of these is that corporate directors have a fiduciary duty to manage the corporation in such a way as to generate the most value for shareholders in the long term. The only caveat is that they may not cause the corporation to violate the law, no matter how much value that might create. As Delaware former Chief Justice Leo Strine once famously said, “Delaware does not charter lawbreakers.”

Any rational director applying these principles would see that Nvidia’s former president and CEO Jensen Huang had to go and cannot come back. Not only do Huang’s alleged affairs—which broke in the media last week—appear to have violated corporate policy; at least one of them may also have jeopardized national security and raised questions about the company’s compliance with export-control laws. Boards have ousted many CEOs over the years for far less.

Corporations hire chief executive officers not because they are superstars or geniuses or well-connected; they hire them to maximize long-term shareholder value within the law. Being a superstar or a genius or well-connected may help with this goal, of course, but the ultimate criterion remains shareholder value. If a CEO destroys value, or if directors determine that someone else would create even more value, then the current CEO must go.

Without a doubt, Jensen Huang knows Nvidia better than anyone else, is an extremely talented CEO, and has created tremendous value for the company’s shareholders. It would take a lot to make a reasonable person believe the company would be better off without him.

Unfortunately, Huang has delivered on that sad standard. Put aside for a minute the most serious issues—Huang’s affair with a woman who may or may not be a Chinese spy and Nvidia’s possible failure to comply with export-control laws. According to multiple media outlets, Huang had a relationship with a subordinate in violation of company policy. That’s normally enough to oust a CEO on its own. Consider Laurent Freixe (Nestle, 2025), Bernard Looney (BP, 2023), Steve Easterbrook (McDonald’s, 2019), Brian Krzanich (Intel, 2018), Mark Hurd (HP, 2010), and Harry Stonecipher (Boeing, 2005). All were terminated (or required to resign) because of improper relationships.

The reasoning here is straightforward: running a gigantic and complex business enterprise is difficult, and while few are up to the task, there is almost always somebody who could do the job as well as the current CEO—and without his baggage.

Conceivably, Huang is so special that, despite his alleged relationship with a subordinate, he would produce more value for shareholders than any alternative candidate. Color me skeptical of that argument, but even if it’s true, there’s also his relationship with a woman who was possibly working for Chinese intelligence.

It’s hard to imagine something worse for Huang to have done than having an affair with a suspected foreign agent. AI is probably America’s most critical industry for national security, and Nvidia is possibly the most important AI company in the world. Few objectives are more important for U.S. national security than keeping Nvidia’s top technology out of Beijing’s hands. Huang and others may take a different view of this goal, but our elected representatives have made their call, reflected in U.S. export controls—that is to say, the law. We are entitled to our opinions about the wisdom of our laws, but we must all obey them.

Still, it would be a mistake to conclude that Nvidia’s directors had to fire Huang simply because of what he had done. Huang’s billionaire friends, fellow CEOs, loyal subordinates, and political pals who argue that his missteps are not disqualifying are, in a sense, right. The board shouldn’t be making moral judgments about Huang (though adultery is morally wrong), punishing him for his delicts (though he does deserve to lose his job), or even removing him because he put national security at risk (though he very likely did so).

The legal duty of Nvidia’s board is to make a business judgment about whether leaving Huang as CEO is likely to generate more long-term value for shareholders than other available candidates. Even if there aren’t many executives who could generate value at Nvidia like Huang can, there are a few who could, and, assuming none has been canoodling with Chinese spies, this becomes an easy decision for the Nvidia board.

This leaves the issue of Nvidia’s perhaps-inadequate compliance with U.S. export controls. Recall that directors are charged with maximizing value for shareholders within the law. Under Delaware’s Caremark doctrine, directors may be personally liable if they knowingly disregard their duty to ensure that the company follows all laws critical to its business operations. For Nvidia, it is hard to imagine laws more critical to its business than export controls intended to keep its most advanced products away from America’s most dangerous adversary.

Nvidia and the U.S. government are still investigating whether the company violated export controls, either intentionally or merely negligently. In any event, now that Nvidia is on notice about such a major problem, the directors must act swiftly to ensure that the company is complying with the law. The last person you would want involved in that effort is the one who created the problem, Jensen Huang. Hence, he has to go, and he can never come back.

Donate

City Journal is a publication of the Manhattan Institute for Policy Research (MI), a leading free-market think tank. Are you interested in supporting the magazine? As a 501(c)(3) nonprofit, donations in support of MI and City Journal are fully tax-deductible as provided by law (EIN #13-2912529).

Further Reading