Los Angeles County child welfare officials had at least six chances to prevent Guojun Xuan and Silvia Zhang from abusing and neglecting their 21 children. That’s according to a new podcast series hosted by New Yorker reporter Ava Kofman, who covered the couple’s surrogacy scandal for the magazine.
Guojun and Silvia paid surrogate mothers across the country to carry their babies, telling each one that Silvia had no other children. It wasn’t until one of the surrogates posted her story on TikTok that others began to realize they had been scammed. Guojun and Silvia’s motivations remain unclear—officials first thought they might have been trafficking the children, but there is no evidence for that. The couple picked up the children from hospitals and brought them back to a bizarre Arcadia compound. There, a team of nannies was responsible for the children’s day-to-day needs. With the couple’s participation and obfuscation, these nannies subjected their charges to physical abuse.
Finally, a reason to check your email.
Sign up for our free newsletter today.
In the incident that led to the couple’s arrest last summer, footage from one of the home’s 32 surveillance cameras shows a two-month-old crying “for a few seconds until a thud or hit is heard,” and then the “crying suddenly stops.” After the nanny’s “attempt to wake him up” is unsuccessful, she shakes him, but he appears unconscious. The couple watched the video and rewatched it, handed the nanny cash, and sent her on her way. (She is still at large in China.) But they waited another day to seek medical care for the child, and Silvia lied about the cause of his injuries at the hospital.
What’s astonishing is that just before the police decided to examine this footage, a social worker from Los Angeles’s Department of Child and Family Services (DCFS) claims to have conducted a visual inspection of the children, concluding, “it is evident there is no neglect and abuse at this time.” When the children were taken into foster care right afterward, many had, according to Kofman, “visible scratches, scars, bruises, and marks, some of which appeared to have been made with a ruler or stick.” It doesn’t seem like that visual inspection was very thorough.
Kofman, who obtained the children’s confidential file from DCFS—presumably through an informant’s leak—says this was hardly the first time DCFS workers ignored the evidence under their noses. At one point, the agency was contacted by a hospital, concerned that the couple failed to visit its premature twins in the NICU on more than two or three occasions, even though the babies were there for weeks. When a nurse was sent to check on the twins after they went home, she encountered another baby, a five-month-old with hydrocephalus—a buildup of fluid in the brain that causes the head to swell visibly. The condition can be fatal if left untreated, and the nurse instructed the couple to get the baby to the ER immediately.
But this didn’t seem to raise alarms, either. Instead, for eight months, the couple was subject to a voluntary case plan in which social workers observed the mother’s parenting techniques and checked to make sure the child was being taken to medical appointments. Another referral said that a three-year-old had bruises on his lower back, left arm, and leg. The child said that it was the result of his mother hitting him, though the file suggests the injuries could have been from the nanny. This report was deemed “unfounded” by the agency.
Perhaps the most egregious instance of malpractice on the part of authorities was when a family court judge asked a psychologist to do a home study of the family. It’s not clear why, but it could be because of the sheer number of surrogacy cases they had. The psychologist visited this home, where surveillance tapes showed children being beaten and experiencing no warmth or nurturing from their caregivers. He wrote that he was “impressed with this family.” He had no concerns about the couple’s ability to raise even more children.
Troublingly, all of the psychologist’s interviews for the study—including with the nannies—used Silvia as the translator. One lawyer asked Kofman, “how do you know you’re really getting the information that you should be getting?” Good question.
As things now stand, both defendants have been charged with conspiracy to commit child abuse, accessory after the fact, and dissuading a witness.
“Reading through the file,” Kofman writes, “I saw that DCFS had been getting tips about Silvia and Guojun for years.” There were “six opportunities when the child welfare system could have intervened, and it repeatedly failed to do so in any meaningful way.” DCFS told her it can’t comment on any of this because of confidentiality rules that supposedly protect the children in these cases. I also contacted DCFS and the Superior Court of Los Angeles County. Both said that they couldn’t comment because of confidentiality.
Across the country, child welfare agencies are engaged in similarly shocking behavior, leaving children in dangerous situations repeatedly. Whether it’s ideological opposition or incompetence that leads employees not to remove children to foster care, the only people the child welfare system seems to be protecting are the adults.