|
Forwarded this email? Sign up for free to have it sent directly to your inbox. |
|
|
|
Good morning,
Today, we’re looking at Mahmoud Khalil’s new book, U.S.–China tech competition, choosing sides on Israel, and PBS’s Crime and Punishment in America.
Write to us at editors@city-journal.org with questions or comments. |
|
|
|
Photo by CHARLY TRIBALLEAU / AFP via Getty Images |
In his book No Land to Stand On, Mahmoud Khalil portrays himself as a martyr persecuted for his pro-Palestine views. But as Tal Fortgang observes in his review, Khalil’s worldview is rife with paranoia, conspiracy theories, and anti-Israel hatred. Khalil glosses over the atrocities of October 7, 2023, minimizes the extremism and terrorist sympathies of the Columbia University protest he helped lead, and persistently frames himself as a victim—even as he’s been treated with “kid gloves” his entire life. Khalil, Fortgang maintains, is simply a con artist.
“Khalil blames Israel alone for his suffering,” Fortgang writes. “It can be hard to understand the worldview of a person who would let his actual oppressors off so easily. The truth is that his ideology is ad hoc and malleable, best characterized as blaming Israel and figuring out the details later.”
Read more here. |
|
|
Recent events suggest that America’s policy of restricting Chinese companies’ access to U.S. markets and tech is beginning to pay off, argues Nathan Picarsic.
CXMT, China’s largest domestic memory-chip manufacturer, and Shanghai Enflame, an AI chip manufacturer, both had successful IPOs. Those outcomes, writes Picarsic, “show that Beijing’s markets reward domestic substitution—which means that Chinese capital markets are sensitive to America’s export restrictions.”
Even more telling, Zhongji Innolight, one of the world’s largest manufacturers of optical transceivers used in datacenters, had a lackluster IPO, which suggests that recent U.S. restrictions on Chinese companies’ access to the American market are also having an effect. Recent U.S. moves on tech competition, Picarsic maintains, “may present a rare case of America getting onto the field in time and with the right playbook.”
Read more. |
|
|
Gates Garcia offers a personal meditation on how he became a strong defender of Israel.
It began, he says, with a lesson he remembered from his parents: “you can tell a lot about a person by the company he keeps.” Applying that lesson to three of the most prominent Israel critics online, he found that “[t]hey replaced wisdom with resentment and traded intellectual curiosity for suspicion.”
Meantime, the other side—represented by figures like Liel Leibowitz, Bishop Robert Barron, Douglas Murray, and others—offered something quite different. “What attracted me to these people wasn’t even their support for Israel. It was that they demonstrated qualities I wanted to cultivate in myself.” “In a world that often obsesses over choosing the winning side, I’d rather choose the company worth keeping,” he writes.
Read it here. |
|
|
Jonathan Clarke reviews Crime and Punishment in America, Lynn Novick and Ken Burns’s new documentary on the American criminal-justice system. While ambitious and well produced, the film, he argues, comes off as too morally sure of itself on a subject for which ambivalence and modesty would be more appropriate.
The documentary “asks us to consider whether retribution is a morally respectable motive and answers its own question in the negative,” he writes. In the process, it gives short shrift to the voices of crime victims and their families.
“A just society must be merciful, but mercy cannot relieve us of the terrible burden of judgment,” Clarke writes. |
|
|
“The war on gig workers is succeeding as was intended—it prevents competition from undermining established workers’ wages. What happens to the gig workers nobody was ever concerned about.” |
|
|
|
A quarterly magazine of urban affairs, published by the Manhattan Institute, edited by Brian C. Anderson. |
|
|
|
Copyright © 2026 Manhattan Institute, All rights reserved.
|
|
|
|
|