Sometimes it’s the little things that drive you over the edge.

During Gotham’s last recession, from 1989 through 1992, the city and state raised taxes by billions of dollars. But what most seemed to enrage residents and business owners, especially small business owners, were the fines and fee increases heaped on top of those taxes.

To help close Gotham’s budget gap back then, agencies within the Dinkins administration embarked on an aggressive policy of fining firms and residents. Officious inspectors oppressively ticketed thousands of retailers for sanitation violations, for example, sometimes for something as trivial as a piece of paper blown by the wind onto the sidewalk in front of their shop. The “nuisance fees,” as the fines were called, resulted in big bucks: fines collected by the city soared 39 percent, from $287 million in 1989 to $398 million by fiscal 1992. But these nuisance fees, often parceled out indiscriminately, also sparked anger and contempt toward the administration and the city’s enforcement agencies.

Now New York is again resorting to higher fines and more tickets to help close its budget gap. The city projects that revenues from violations will increase to $662 million next fiscal year, up by $205 million—or 45 percent—in just two years. By contrast, the city’s ticketing revenues grew by just $20 million, or 5 percent, in the previous four years as a whole.

Much of the additional revenue will come from parking tickets, which, according to a recent study by the city’s Independent Budget Office, seem to offer the best return on “investment” for the city, costing the city just 22 cents to administer for every $1 in parking fines it hands out, compared with fines for everything from housing-code violations to improper bagging of garbage, which cost the city more than the revenue they bring in. To take advantage of that neat spread, the Bloomberg administration is even hiring 300 new traffic enforcement officers. Lest anyone think this is merely a minor irritation, earlier this year Crain’s New York Business reported that one small city courier service is expecting to pay $15,000 more in parking fines this year because of the city’s aggressive new policy. That’s on top of higher taxes and increases in parking fees.

The projected revenue bonanza is yet another sign of an administration hell bent on raising revenues by any means possible, at whatever cost to the economic health of the city. To justify this new policy, the mayor has been disingenuous, remarking that if citizens and businesses want to avoid higher fines, they should obey the law. That sentiment, of course, ignores the fact that the city has a dense and Byzantine civil code filled with dozens of obscure rules impossible to follow to the letter.

During the ticketing blitz in the early 1990s, sanitation inspectors hovered outside greengroceries and ticketed owners as soon as a passerby dropped some garbage in front of the store. In the latest round of violations madness, according to reports in the daily newspapers, New Yorkers are discovering that it is illegal to sit on the steps of a subway station or for a retailer to display his phone number on an awning. In either case, the lessons are the same: if some streetcorner bureaucrat wants to ticket you, he pretty much can find some law that you’ve violated in New York.

The mayor, increasingly tone deaf, seems unconcerned by how all of this might affect the atmosphere in a city already groaning over more than 100,000 lost jobs, higher taxes, and the ongoing threat of more terrorist attacks. After opining that New Yorkers should simply obey the law, the mayor blamed someone else for the ticketing mess—the city council. If New Yorkers don’t like all these fines, they should get the city council to change the laws, said the businessman mayor, sounding as if he is a complete stranger to the legislative process in New York.

After that tactic didn’t gain much traction, the administration tried to persuade everyone it was all a big misunderstanding, releasing statistics that showed the total number of violations written in the city this year are declining. Left unsaid, of course, is that the city is in the process of hiring all those extra parking enforcement agents, and that right there in its budget—in black and white—the city is projecting that revenues from these sources will increase substantially.

The ticketing controversy is perhaps the most revealing moment in the Bloomberg administration so far. Reasonable people might have a discussion and debate about whether raising taxes or cutting services is the most effective way to deal with a budget crisis. But there is little within the realm of good government that justifies an administration that will shake down its citizens and its businesses for every last nickel, making ordinary citizens feel like lawbreakers just to balance the books.

What New York needs right now from the mayor is effective management of government and inspiring leadership. Instead, it has gotten a mayor who only seems to know how to be a tax collector—or a meter maid.


City Journal is a publication of the Manhattan Institute for Policy Research (MI), a leading free-market think tank. Are you interested in supporting the magazine? As a 501(c)(3) nonprofit, donations in support of MI and City Journal are fully tax-deductible as provided by law (EIN #13-2912529).

Further Reading

Up Next