City Journal Home.
SEARCH SITE
Advanced Search
 
City Journal Autumn 2009.
City Journal Current Issue
 

Bruce S. Thornton
Golden Threads
Former Muslim Ibn Warraq stands up for the West.
17 August 2007

Selected Responses:

Sent by Jeffrey Cass on 08-17-2007:

You obviously don't know the first thing about Edward Said or the complexities of his work, which are more than just Orientalism. You don't mention, for example, Culture and Imperialism, which acknowledges certain shortcomings in Orientalism. Finally, Said is not speaking of HISTORICAL truths, but representational ones—how the West REPRESENTS the Orient.

I'm surprised that so many fall for Lewis's (and others) thundering, conservative claptrap. Bush and his crew have obviously been reading people like Warraq, whose ideological grind utterly distorts Said's contributions. Read some more in the field before you start shilling for conservative demagogues.

Bruce Thornton responds: Mr. Cass tries to salvage Said's incoherence by making a distinction between "historical" truths and "representational" ones. But isn't the "representation" itself a fact of history, one that's either true or false? Said's critics argue convincingly that Said's history of the West's "representation" is a distortion based on selective, misinterpreted evidence.

As for Cass's remarks about Bernard Lewis: that's sort of like admiring Woody Allen's pugilistic skills while denigrating Muhammed Ali's.

 

More by Bruce S. Thornton:
Dupes
No We Can’t
Islam Without Apologetics
More . . .
Recently in Books and Culture:
You Say Potato, I’ll Say Potato
Neither God nor Devil
The Crescent and the Continent
This story was cited in:
Dyspepsia Generation
Free Republic
Cinnamon Stillwell


Home |  About City Journal |  City Journal Books |  Archives |  Links
Contact Us |  Subscribe Print |  Subscribe Online |  RSS |  Advertise |  CJ Mobile

CONTACT INFO:

subscriptions: (800) 562-1973 • editorial: (212) 599-7000 • fax: (212) 599-0371

Copyright The Manhattan Institute