A quarterly magazine of urban affairs, published by the Manhattan Institute, edited by Brian C. Anderson.
• • • • • • • • • • • • • • •
The Nursery: No Longer Immune
Vulgarity finally reaches childrens books, but Maurice Sendak saves the day.
30 September 2011
The cheapeners of American culture have invaded Broadway and Hollywood, TV sitcoms, rap music, popular song, novels, magazines, and, of course, the Internet. But throughout all this degradation, one area was assumed to be off limits: the nursery.
Ah, but that was before the appearance of a childrens book entitled Go the F**k to Sleep. With the aid of Ricardo Cortéss colorful illustrations, novelist Adam Mansbach has managed to vulgarize a universal experience—getting children to shut their eyes and go off to dreamland without asking for yet another glass of water, yet another trip to the bathroom, yet another bedtime story.
Its no secret that mothers and fathers find this a difficult time in child development; not for nothing are those years called the Terrible Twos. But healthy parents handle it with patience and grit, whispering their grumbles to each other, and getting on with life. This slim volume, however, is not concerned with healthy responses. A typical rhyme reads:
The tiger reclines in the simmering jungle,
The back cover of Go the F**k to Sleep trails praise from National Public Radio (Incredibly appealing), Newsweek (Delightfully obscene), and the Washington Post (May just redefine the modern parenting market). These are exactly the sort of institutions appalled by the sight of little girls wearing lipstick and eye shadow at beauty contests for eight-year-olds, or by the sounds of fathers and mothers screaming death threats at a Little League umpire. But its all of a piece: the stealing of childhood from children by pushing the tarted-up outfits, the cheesy bush-league behavior, the self-congratulatory cocky-doody language of adults with few standards and no taste.
Its instructive to compare Go the F**k to Sleep with a new book by an old man. In Bumble-Ardy, Maurice Sendak, 83, the doyen of childrens books, tells the tale of a pig who never gets to celebrate his birthday. Sendak doesnt shy away from unpleasant reality:
When Bumble was eight
The difference is that Sendaks book uses wit, along with a respect for language, for subject matter, and, most importantly, for childrens minds. Mansbachs book is coarse in content, and awed only by praise and profits. In the present culture, it was bound to succeed, and, indeed, it became a #1 New York Times bestseller. From there, it could only go down, in every sense of the word.
Stefan Kanfer, a contributing editor of City Journal and a former editor of Time, is the author, most recently, of Tough Without a Gun, a biography of Humphrey Bogart.