A quarterly magazine of urban affairs, published by the Manhattan Institute, edited by Brian C. Anderson.
• • • • • • • • • • • • • • •
A Tale of Two Cities
Washington and Hollywood, both tone-deaf to American attitudes
23 March 2010
Washington, D.C. and Hollywood are two cities suffering from the same condition: theyve not only become completely alienated from the people theyre meant to serve, theyre bizarrely blind to the fact of that alienation. Like deranged narcissists in a hall of mirrors, both our lawmakers and our culture-makers blow kisses at their own reflections, see a million kisses coming back their way, and think, Oh, look, they love melove me!
For glaring proof in Washington, we have the passage of the health-care bill. Recently the Washington Post ran an op-ed by former Carter pollster Pat Caddell and former Clinton pollster Douglas E. Schoen expressing their amazement that Obama and the Democrats would go forward with this bill in the face of overwhelming evidence that the public doesnt want it. Caddella moderate Democrat who sometimes sports a T-shirt reading IM GRUMPY BECAUSE YOURE DOPEYand Schoen are baffled that the Democrats continue to grow and grow and grow the government despite polls that show Americans feel the federal apparatus is now an immediate threat to their civil rights and is no longer operating with the consent of the governed.
And yet, even after losing a Senate seat in blue-on-blue Massachusetts almost entirely because of the health care and big government issues, the Democrats plunged forward, certain that were going to like what theyre forcing us to eat.
To get a sense of the psychology behind this self-destructive self-deception, lets take a look at a similar act in D.C.s ideological sister city, some 3,000 miles away. Here, Universal studios recently released Green Zone, a $100 million antiIraq War movie, despite the box-office failures of over a dozen similarly themed films. Matt Damon stars as the soldier who discoversthough in reality, this is provably untruethat the Bush administration lied about Saddam Husseins weapons of mass destruction in order to drag us into war. Operation Shock and Awe was nothing compared with the way this picture bombed. HBOs World War II series, The Pacific, also did only modest business, its chances possibly poisoned by executive producer Tom Hanks idiotic remarks that America had wanted to annihilate [the Japanese] because they were different, and that this made the war in the Pacific similar to todays wars against Islamic terror.
As a result of these two failures, showbiz trade magazine Variety ran an almost hilariously purblind article saying that Hollywood was calling a truce on making war films because with U.S. troops embroiled in combat in Iraq and Afghanistan, American audiences continue to suffer from war fatigue.
Yeah, that must be it. It couldnt be that were nauseated by a bunch of showbiz yahoos depicting our troops and leaders as evil while theyre in the field defending us. Or wait, maybe it is: the one filmthe single filmthat, while taking no political position on these wars, nonetheless treated our military with deep honor, respect, and patriotismHBOs brilliant Taking Chancewas one of the networks signal successes despite the mainstream medias blithering negative reviews.
Heres the thing. The American people want government that acts in keeping with our principles of free markets, self-reliance, and individual liberty. The people want culture that depicts the moral order as we know it is, not as sequestered elites dream it should be. But in Hollywood and in Washington, they cant hear the people because theyre making too much noise talking to themselves, confirming themselves, and loving themselves.
They say that Washington is Hollywood for ugly people. But as long as our leaders and artists are displaying such blindness, arrogance, and narcissism, theyre all ugly.
Andrew Klavan is a City Journal contributing editor and the author of such best-selling novels as Dont Say a Word and Empire of Lies. His new thriller for young adults, The Long Way Home, is out now.